Solar

Should you buy solar shingles? Complete 2024 guide

Key points
  • Solar shingles are power-generating roof tiles that offer a sleek aesthetic at an added cost.
  • Solar shingles cost more than solar panels and have a much longer payback period.
  • The cost of solar shingles is comparable to the combined cost of a new roof and traditional solar panels.

Solar shingles are roof shingles that can generate solar energy. A solar-shingle roof can be almost indistinguishable from a regular roof. 

You should buy solar shingles if you want solar power but don’t want it to stand out. Despite the numerous benefits and qualities the best solar panels offer, many homeowners think large rectangular blocks on their roofs are somewhat unsightly. 

With solar shingles, you can enjoy the benefits of solar power, such as reduced energy bills and a decreased carbon footprint, while also having a sleek-looking roof. 

Request Quote
Our Top Choice

What are solar shingles?

Solar shingles are a clever combination of roof shingles and solar photovoltaic (PV) cells. A classic example of building-integrated photovoltaics (BIPV), a solar shingle has solar cells integrated into its surface. Based on factors such as energy needs and roof orientation, some or all of a home’s roof tiles can be solar shingles.

Unlike traditional solar modules, which are immediately noticeable on a roof, the low-profile design of solar shingles helps them blend in with their nonsolar counterparts.

Solar shingles were invented by Dow Chemical Company, which first launched a commercial solar roof tile in 2009. However, the technology gained widespread attention when Tesla announced its revolutionary solar roof in 2016.

How do solar shingles differ from solar panels?

The main difference between solar shingles and traditional solar panels is that solar panels are installed on top of your current roof, while solar shingles replace the existing roof. 

Since solar panels are not required to mimic a building material, they are designed primarily with performance in mind.

Solar shingles, on the other hand, have design limitations, which lead to slightly lower efficiency. Design limitations also affect the size, material and expected life span of the shingles. The table below outlines the key differences between solar shingles and solar panels.

FeatureSolar ShinglesSolar Panels
Life span20–30 years25–40 years
Material Copper indium gallium selenide (CIGS) or passivated emitter and rear cell (PERC) monocrystalline PVMonocrystalline silicon or PERC
Size12–15 in. by 45–86 in.Around 65-by-35 in.
Power Output13–72 W Up to 550 W
Efficiency Range15%–20%Up to 24%
Provider Our Rating Manufacturer’s Warranty Workmanship Warranty Get Started
4.6
25 years 5 years Request Quote
4.6
25 years 25 years Request Quote
4.6
25 years 25 years Request Quote
4.3
25 years 10 years Request Quote
4.3
25 years 10 years Request Quote
Provider Our Rating Manufacturer’s Warranty Workmanship Warranty Get Started
4.6
25 years 5 years Request Quote
4.6
25 years 25 years Request Quote
4.6
25 years 25 years Request Quote
4.3
25 years 10 years Request Quote
4.3
25 years 10 years Request Quote

What should you consider when choosing solar shingles?

Solar shingles are still a relatively new technology, so there are several things to consider before committing — including cost, performance, durability and appearance. When evaluating multiple solar shingle options, aim to find an optimum balance between these and other relevant factors.

Energy production

A solar shingle’s power rating determines the number of shingles your roof requires to generate electricity. A shingle with a high power rating will provide ample power in a smaller space. This is particularly helpful if you have a small roof or a roof with a smaller South-facing section, which is the ideal direction for North American systems.

Solar shingles can generate from 15 W to more than 70 W based on the major options on the market, including Tesla, SunTegra, GAF Timberline and CertainTeed. Brand and model will affect energy output. The Tesla solar shingle, for instance, generates 71.67 W, while the GAF Timberline solar shingle generates 45 W of peak power.

Solar shingles can vary in size, which is why manufacturers also offer a power generation value per square foot. For example, Tesla’s shingles generate a little more than 15 W per square foot of surface area.

Installation

Installing solar roof shingles is somewhat similar to traditional roof shingle installation, making it more complex and time-consuming than standard solar panel installation. This is in part because installers must tear off your existing roof. Some solar shingle brands require you to replace your entire roof, while others can replace just parts of it, making the installation somewhat cheaper and faster.

Aside from this, the complexity of a roof can also affect the ease, speed and cost of the installation process. For example, it is more complex to install solar shingles on a roof with too many obstacles. Similarly, a roof with an orientation or pitch that does not allow it to receive ample sunlight will need more solar shingles to compensate for the reduced performance, adding to the time, effort and cost of installation.

Durability and life span

Similar to traditional roof shingles, solar shingles are exposed directly to harsh sun, rain, snow and hail — which means durability is key.

The best solar shingle options on the market are tested for durability with mechanical stress tests and hail impact tests. When considering a solar shingle model, verify that the manufacturer has tested the product for as many durability tests as possible. This will help you get a better return on your investment.

Warranty

Most reputable solar shingles come with a 25-year product warranty, which is the minimum length you should look for. Not all warranties are equal, though; you should check for these types:

  • Product warranty: A product warranty is the most basic warranty that comes with almost every solar shingle on the market. This warranty covers any manufacturing defects for 20–25 years.
  • Power generation guarantee: This is a guarantee that promises a minimum power output from your solar shingles for their entire life span. For example, Tesla guarantees its solar roof will generate 95 percent of its rated power for the first five years with a 0.5% maximum annual decrease in power output for the following 20 years.
  • Weatherization/wind warranty: A weatherization warranty backs the ability of the solar shingles to protect your home from the elements, such as wind and rain. Some companies offer a warranty only against wind, promising protection from high wind speeds. For example, the CertainTeed Solstice comes with a 10-year warranty against 110-mph wind speeds.

Materials

Most major solar shingle products integrate a thin-film solar cell into a glass or steel tile. This often makes them stronger than traditional asphalt shingles. Currently, copper indium gallium selenide (CIGS) is the most common thin-film composition used in solar shingles.

Thin-film solar cells have been in commercial use for a while. They may not be as widespread as crystalline silicon (which is used in most solar panels), but their flexibility and lightweight construction make them perfect for portable or BIPV applications, such as flexible solar panels or solar shingles.

Appearance

The earliest solar shingles were simply solar cells attached to otherwise regular roof shingles. These shingles, though not as apparent as solar panels, were easy to distinguish from regular roof shingles.

However, technological advancement in the industry has led to innovative designs that make the “solar” component of solar shingles almost invisible. Most solar shingles blend in seamlessly with surrounding roof shingles. Many solar shingles are even designed to look like traditional asphalt roof shingles.

Where can you buy solar shingles?

Although solar shingles haven’t captured the solar PV market like the ever so popular solar panels have, a significant number of reputable companies have launched their own solar roofing products. Here are some examples:

  • Tesla
  • GAF Energy
  • CertainTeed (Saint Gobain)
  • Luma Solar
  • SunTegra Solar

Most of the above brands offer installation services, but you can also install their products through authorized installation partners. For example, Green Home Systems is an authorized installer for CertainTeed’s solar shingles.

Request Quote
Our Top Choice

How much do solar shingles cost to install?

The cost of solar shingles varies based on brand, system size, roof size and pitch, and overall installation complexity. Installing a solar roof system on a typical American home may cost between $25,000 and $60,000 but can range up to $70,000 or more, according to Axia Solar.

Solar shingles are more expensive than solar panels, which cost an average of $2.86 per watt. By comparison, solar shingles cost from $4.80 to $6.40 per watt, according to Axia. While this may seem high, the total cost to install solar shingles is comparable to the combined cost of a new conventional roof and a traditional solar panel system.

How much does solar help you save in energy costs?

The average payback period for solar panels in the United States is less than 10 years, while the life of a solar power system is 25–30 years. This means solar power can offer around two decades of free electricity. Considering the nation’s average electricity bill of around $137 per month, this can amount to significant lifetime savings, particularly in states with high electricity costs, such as California.

Despite solar shingles’ high price, the cost of solar products, including panels and shingles, has dropped drastically over the past decade. At the same time, the cost of conventional grid power is constantly rising.

Incentives

A solar roof is a solar power system, which means your solar shingles will be eligible for most or all of the solar incentives and rebates available for traditional rooftop solar systems. This includes federal, state-level and local incentives offered by municipalities and utility companies. 

The most important solar incentive available in the United States is the federal solar tax credit. Also known as the solar investment tax credit (ITC), it allows you to deduct 30% of your system’s cost from your income tax payments. For example, if a solar shingle system costs $50,000, you can get a noteworthy income tax credit of $15,000.

In most states, solar shingles are also eligible for state-sponsored solar loans such as the PACE financing program, which allows you to finance your solar roof and repay the borrowed amount through an addition to your property taxes. Your solar company can apply for the solar incentives on your behalf.

What’s next?

Solar shingles have quickly gone from an interesting new invention to the logical next step in the evolution of solar photovoltaics. Their ability to power a home while being inconspicuous sets them apart from traditional solar panels. Moreover, the dropping price of solar shingles is now making them a sound investment — especially in cases where a new roof is required.

If you are interested in exploring solar shingles for your home, check out our top choices for solar or reach out to reputable solar companies or roofers and compare quotes from at least three installers. We recommend starting with Tesla and Green Home Systems, two of the most reliable solar shingle installers in the country based on our research.

Editorial note: The name “Homefront” refers to the alliance between USA TODAY and Home Solutions that publishes review, comparison, and informational articles designed to help USA TODAY readers make smarter purchasing and investment decisions about their home. Under the alliance, Homefront provides and publishes research and articles about home service and home improvement topics.

Homefront has an affiliate disclosure policy. The opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the Homefront editorial staff alone (see About Homefront). Homefront adheres to strict editorial integrity standards. The information is believed to be accurate as of the publish date, but always check the provider’s website for the most current information.

Go Back to Top
More on this topic...
solar
solar panels on roof of a home
solar panels on the roof of a house